Inksticks for Indentify

[AskiaLuna]

Hi, I find ink sticks from time to time I can not identify and would like to know what those are.

Especially because I am looking for good purchases.

https://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B00JVSMWA8/ref=ox_sc_saved_title_1?smid=A2HSFPQG9EH8HP&th=1

https://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B00JVSO65M/ref=ox_sc_saved_title_1?smid=A2HSFPQG9EH8HP&th=1

[multapaakku]

All these are produced by 徳记胡开文 Deji Hukaiwen factory. Personally, I’ve never used their ink, but as far as I know their reputation is not very good.

The first one is called “唐墨” (Tang Mo), an oil soot ink (it says 书画油烟墨, “calligraphy and painting oil soot ink”, on the box). Many factories make some version of the “唐墨” mold and it is usually a middle-grade oil soot ink, but the exact recipe varies from one factory to another. 纯松烟 is literally pure pine soot.

For historical reasons, there are many factories with Hukaiwen in their name. Talking about new ink, 屯溪胡开文 Tunxi Hukaiwen (registered trademark 胡开文 Hukaiwen) and 绩溪胡开文 Jixi Hukaiwen (registered trademark 苍佩室 Cang Pei Shi) are generally considered good, 歙县老胡开文 She County Old Hukaiwen (registered trademark 李廷珪 Li Tinggui) is supplied at Inkston. Tunxi and She County Old Hukaiwen were two of the state-owned ink factories in the last century.

• This reply was modified 6 years ago by multapaakku.

[ericmarie]

I agree. These inksticks are very “basic”. It can work, of course, but it is not excellent.

[AskiaLuna]

Thanks for the answer, I haven’t looked in here for a long time.

I wanted to know if the description oil and pine soot was correct, because they are often exchanged and somehow all ink sticks that are available in Germany are often described as Pine soot even though they are different varieties.

Here I have the impression that only industrial soot is student grade and everything that has other soot types is at least professional grade. So student grade pine and oil soot ink exists. I just thought it was interesting, I didn’t buy it, I wanted to wait and see.

I have a small cheap industrial soot ink stick for on the go-to practice in my sketchbook. but I didn’t notice a real difference to the others only that the ink is not as cool as from my pine soot ink stick

[Author]

Posts